You can whip this recipe up in five to ten minutes, which is faster than most of you can drive to Wendy’s and buy one yourself. Heck, that’s faster than it takes me to load up my four children in the car and make them put on their seat belts. Watch this video to see how quick and easy it is to whip up this Paleo frosty recipe:
Watch on Youtube
You can use either almond or coconut milk with this frosty. The almond milk is more mild. The coconut milk leaves a stronger coconut taste but makes the frosty creamier. If you’re really ambitious, you could mix the two and kind of get the best of both worlds. More or less honey can be used depending on how ripe your banana is. The riper the banana, the sweeter it is. If you don’t have raw cacao powder, regular cocoa powder will do just fine.If you like it thicker, either use less milk or add more ice cubes. So the next time I have an urge to get a Wendy’s Frosty I will be making this instead!
Some other tips from readers are to freeze the bananas, which makes it colder, creamier and smoother. Tip from reader Kelly from my Paleo Facebook group – “I make this whenever I want a treat. However, after making it a few times with the banana, I started subbing it with Almond butter. I like it much better with Almond butter than banana…. Just a tip to try!”*Please note that most of the links on this page are affiliate links. This means if you click on a link and purchase, you will receive the same price, but I will receive a little money for referring you to the product. This helps keep this blog free for you. I truly appreciate you supporting my blog.
What are your biggest weakness when it comes to fast food? We need to find ways around wanting these foods for the sake of our health. Comment below what food you would like to see a healthier copycat version of on our blog!
If you like this Wendy’s Copycat Paleo Frosty Recipe, you may also like these recipes:
Paleo Wendy's Copycat Frosty Recipe
This frosty recipe is quick, easy and tastes just like the real thing without all the questionable ingredients.
Place all ingredients in a blender.
Starting on low speed, blend everything together, slowly turning the speed up to medium. Blend until smooth and creamy.
Makes 2, 8-9 ounce servings.